From Ancient Birth Stools to Modern Hospitals: Why Upright Childbirth Positions Are Making a Comeback
Why Upright Birth Positions Are Making a Comeback: What Ancient Childbirth Can Teach Modern Medicine For much of human history, childbirth did not happen with a woman lying flat on her back in a hospital bed. Across diff…
Why Upright Birth Positions Are Making a Comeback: What Ancient Childbirth Can Teach Modern Medicine
For much of human history, childbirth did not happen with a woman lying flat on her back in a hospital bed. Across different societies and periods, women have used positions that allow them to sit, squat, kneel, stand or move during labour. These positions were often supported by midwives, relatives or specially designed birth stools.
Today, modern medicine has changed the environment in which most births take place, but some of these older practices are receiving renewed attention. Researchers and health organisations are increasingly recognising that allowing women to move and choose comfortable childbirth positions can be beneficial when there is no medical reason to restrict movement.
The discussion is not about declaring one position universally better than another. Instead, it is about recognising that labour is dynamic and that a woman's position can change as contractions become stronger, the baby descends and her medical needs evolve.
Childbirth Was Once Far More Upright
Historical evidence shows that upright positions were an important part of childbirth in several ancient societies. Ancient Egyptian evidence is particularly interesting because images, written sources and archaeological discoveries provide clues about how women gave birth.
Research into ancient Egyptian childbirth describes women using squatting positions, sometimes with their feet supported by bricks, while other evidence points to the use of birth chairs or stools. The University College London Digital Egypt collection notes depictions associated with childbirth in which the mother squatted on birth bricks.
Historical research has also identified the development of birth stools from earlier forms of brick-supported childbirth. A 2023 archaeological study examining Egyptian birth chairs concluded that these structures evolved from arrangements of bricks that allowed a woman to squat or semi-squat before developing into more recognisable birth chairs.
The historical record should not be interpreted as evidence that every woman in every ancient society gave birth in exactly the same way. Childbirth practices varied according to culture, location, social circumstances and period. Nevertheless, the evidence demonstrates that lying flat was not the only traditional approach.
In many settings, midwives played an important role in supporting women physically and emotionally. The use of upright positions allowed the mother to change posture according to her comfort and the progress of labour.
Why Gravity May Help During Labour
There is a straightforward physical explanation for why upright positions may be useful during labour.
When a woman is standing, kneeling, sitting or squatting, gravity can work in the same general direction as the baby's descent through the birth canal. Movement may also help the mother find positions that feel more comfortable as contractions progress.
Squatting, for example, changes the angle of the pelvis and may provide greater freedom of movement than lying completely flat. Kneeling or being on all fours can also allow a woman to shift her weight and adjust her posture during contractions.
However, the science is more complicated than simply saying that gravity makes childbirth easier. Labour involves the interaction of the uterus, cervix, pelvis, baby's position, maternal movement and many other factors. A position that feels helpful to one woman may be uncomfortable or unsuitable for another.
This is why modern medical guidance generally focuses on supporting movement and informed choice rather than prescribing one universal birth position.
Research Finds Benefits From Upright Positions
Scientific research provides some support for allowing women to remain upright and mobile during the first stage of labour.
A Cochrane review examining 25 studies involving more than 5,200 women found that women assigned to upright or ambulant positions during the first stage of labour had a labour that was approximately one hour and 22 minutes shorter on average than women in recumbent positions. The review also reported lower rates of caesarean birth and epidural use among women in upright or mobile groups, although the researchers cautioned that the quality and design of the studies varied.
The findings have also been considered by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG). Its guidance reports that research comparing upright positions such as walking, sitting, standing and kneeling with recumbent positions found a shorter first stage of labour among women using upright positions.
These findings are important because prolonged labour can be physically and emotionally exhausting. Giving women opportunities to move may therefore be one way of improving the experience of labour, particularly when movement is medically appropriate.
What Happens During the Pushing Stage?
The evidence becomes more complicated during the second stage of labour, when the woman is pushing and the baby is being born.
Some studies have found that upright or lateral positions may reduce the likelihood of certain interventions. ACOG cites evidence associating upright or lateral positions with fewer abnormal fetal heart-rate patterns, fewer episiotomies and fewer operative vaginal births in some research.
However, there are also potential disadvantages. The same evidence has raised concerns about a possible increase in second-degree perineal tears and blood loss greater than 500 millilitres among women using upright positions during the second stage. These findings demonstrate why childbirth cannot be reduced to a simple argument that upright is always better than lying down.
The World Health Organization similarly acknowledges that the evidence has both potential benefits and possible harms. For women without epidural analgesia, WHO recommends allowing them to choose their birth position, including upright positions. It also stresses that women should not be forced into a particular position.
Why Do Many Women Give Birth Lying Down Today?
If upright childbirth has such a long history, why did lying down become so common in modern hospitals?
One major reason is the development of modern obstetric care. Hospitals require healthcare professionals to monitor the mother and baby, perform examinations and provide medical interventions when necessary. A woman lying on a bed can sometimes make these procedures easier for healthcare workers.
However, convenience for medical staff does not necessarily mean that remaining in one position is best for every woman.
ACOG notes that the traditional supine position can have disadvantages, including supine hypotension and more frequent fetal heart-rate decelerations. Its guidance therefore supports frequent position changes when they improve comfort and fetal positioning and when the positions still allow appropriate monitoring and treatment.
This does not mean that lying down is dangerous or inappropriate in every birth. Rather, it highlights the importance of flexibility.
Modern Medicine Is Rediscovering Freedom of Movement
The growing recognition of movement during labour reflects a broader change in maternity care.
Instead of treating childbirth as a process in which the patient simply follows instructions, modern woman-centred care increasingly emphasises communication, informed choice and respect for the mother's preferences.
The WHO recommends a model of intrapartum care that places women and their babies at the centre of decision-making. Its guidance encourages freedom of movement during early labour and supports a woman's ability to choose her birth position.
WHO's maternal health guidance also describes mobility in labour and birth position of choice as important elements of quality, respectful maternity care.
This approach does not mean that women should reject medical advice. Instead, it means that medical professionals and mothers can work together to determine which position is appropriate at a particular moment.
Epidurals Can Change the Options
Pain relief is another factor that can affect childbirth positions.
Women who receive epidural analgesia may have reduced sensation and movement in their legs, making some positions difficult or unsafe without assistance. Nevertheless, modern maternity care can still offer alternative positions where appropriate.
WHO's recommendations specifically address birth positions for women with and without epidural analgesia, while emphasising that maternal and fetal wellbeing must remain central to the decision.
ACOG also recommends supporting position changes when they can be safely combined with appropriate monitoring and treatment.
In other words, having an epidural does not automatically mean that a woman must remain completely still, but the available choices should be discussed with the healthcare team.
There Is No Perfect Childbirth Position
Perhaps the most important lesson from both history and modern research is that there is no single perfect childbirth position.
A woman may prefer standing during one contraction, kneeling during another and lying on her side when she becomes tired. Another woman may feel more comfortable sitting or squatting. Someone else may need to remain in a particular position because of an epidural, fetal monitoring, complications or another medical consideration.
The safest option can change throughout labour.
Medical professionals must therefore balance maternal comfort and freedom of movement with the condition of the baby, the progress of labour and any medical complications. WHO specifically says that women should be supported in positions they find comfortable while ensuring that the baby's wellbeing can be adequately monitored.
Ancient Wisdom and Modern Evidence Can Coexist
The history of childbirth demonstrates that modern medicine did not invent the idea of moving during labour. For thousands of years, women in different cultures used squatting, kneeling, sitting and other positions.
What has changed is the scientific ability to study these practices systematically.
Modern research does not simply confirm everything ancient societies did, nor does it suggest that hospitals should return to historical childbirth practices without modification. Instead, research helps identify which traditional approaches may have physiological or practical value and under what circumstances they can be safely used.
The result is a more balanced understanding of childbirth: technology and medical intervention are essential when complications arise, but they do not necessarily require every woman to remain in one position throughout labour.
The Future of Childbirth May Be More Flexible
The return of interest in upright birth positions is not a rejection of modern obstetrics. It is an argument for flexibility.
A hospital bed, fetal monitoring, epidural anaesthesia, emergency procedures and other medical technologies can all be valuable when needed. At the same time, a woman should not automatically lose the ability to move or choose a comfortable position simply because she is giving birth in a medical facility.
The evidence from Cochrane, WHO and ACOG suggests that mobility and position changes can have meaningful benefits, particularly during the first stage of labour, while the evidence for the pushing stage requires a more careful assessment of benefits and risks.
Ultimately, childbirth is not a one-position event. It is a constantly changing process involving the mother, baby and healthcare team. The best approach is one that combines evidence-based medicine with respect for the woman's comfort, preferences and individual medical circumstances.
The ancient practice of giving birth upright therefore offers an interesting lesson for modern maternity care: sometimes progress does not mean abandoning the past. It can mean examining old practices with modern scientific tools, keeping what is useful and adapting it to today's standards of safe and respectful childbirth.
Version 1.0. LDCP Network stories are edited before publication and updated as facts change. Spotted an error? Tell our editors.